Java 实现基于Redis的分布式可重入锁

之前在 Java实现基于的Redis的分布式锁 这篇文章中，已经实现了加锁的逻辑，但是有个缺点，就是不可重入，任何重入锁的尝试都会导致死锁的发生，想了一下，这个问题可以解决。

 

 

Thinking

 

如何实现可重入？

 

首先锁信息(指redis中lockKey关联的value值) 必须得设计的能负载更多信息，之前non-reentrant时value直接就是一个超时时间，但是要实现可重入单超时时间是不够的，必须要标识锁是被谁持有的，也就是说要标识分布式环境中的线程，还要记录锁被入了多少次。

 

 

如何在分布式线程中标识唯一线程？

 

MAC地址 + jvm进程ID + 线程ID（或者线程地址都行）,三者结合即可唯一分布式环境中的线程。

 

 

实现

 

锁的信息采用json存储，格式如下：

 

 

 

 代码框架还是和之前实现的非重入的差不多，重点是lock方法，代码已有非常详细的注释

 

package cc.lixiaohui.lock.redis;

import java.io.IOException;
import java.net.SocketAddress;
import java.util.concurrent.TimeUnit;

import org.slf4j.Logger;
import org.slf4j.LoggerFactory;

import redis.clients.jedis.Jedis;
import cc.lixiaohui.lock.AbstractLock;
import cc.lixiaohui.lock.Lock;
import cc.lixiaohui.lock.time.nio.client.TimeClient;
import cc.lixiaohui.lock.util.LockInfo;

/**
 * 基于Redis的SETNX操作实现的分布式锁, 获取锁时最好用tryLock(long time, TimeUnit unit), 以免网路问题而导致线程一直阻塞.
 * <a href="http://redis.io/commands/setnx">SETNC操作参考资料.</a>
 *
 * <p><b>可重入实现关键:</b>
 * <ul>
 * <li>在分布式环境中如何确定一个线程? <i><b>mac地址 + jvm pid + threadId</b></i> (mac地址唯一, jvm
 * pid在单机内唯一, threadId在单jvm内唯一)</li>
 * <li>任何一个线程从redis拿到value值后都需要能确定 该锁是否被自己持有, 因此value值要有以下特性: 保存持有锁的主机(mac), jvm
 * pid, 持有锁的线程ID, 重复持有锁的次数</li>
 * </ul></p>
 * <p>
 * redis中value设计如下(in json):
 * <pre>
 * {
 *  expires : expire time in long
 *  mac : mac address of lock holder's machine
 *  pid : jvm process id
 *  threadId : lock holder thread id
 *  count : hold count(for use of reentrancy)
 * }
 * 由{@link LockInfo LockInfo}表示.
 * </pre>
 *
 * <b>Usage Example:</b>
 * <pre>
 *  {@link Lock} lock = new {@link ReentrantLock}(jedis, "lockKey", lockExpires, timeServerAddr);
 *  if (lock.tryLock(3, TimeUnit.SECONDS)) {
 *      try {
 *          // do something
 *      } catch (Exception e) {
 *          lock.unlock();
 *      }
 *  }
 * </pre>
 * </p>
 *
 * @author lixiaohui
 * @date 2016年9月15日 下午2:52:38
 *
 */
public class ReentrantLock extends AbstractLock {

    private Jedis jedis;

    private TimeClient timeClient;

    // 锁的名字
    protected String lockKey;

    // 锁的有效时长(毫秒)
    protected long lockExpires;

    private static final Logger logger = LoggerFactory.getLogger(ReentrantLock.class);

    public ReentrantLock(Jedis jedis, String lockKey, long lockExpires, SocketAddress timeServerAddr) throws IOException {
        this.jedis = jedis;
        this.lockKey = lockKey;
        this.lockExpires = lockExpires;
        timeClient = new TimeClient(timeServerAddr);
    }

    // 阻塞式获取锁的实现
    protected boolean lock(boolean useTimeout, long time, TimeUnit unit, boolean interrupt) throws InterruptedException {
        if (interrupt) {
            checkInterruption();
        }

        // 超时控制 的时间可以从本地获取, 因为这个和锁超时没有关系, 只是一段时间区间的控制
        long start = localTimeMillis();
        long timeout = unit.toMillis(time); // if !useTimeout, then it's useless

        // walkthrough
        // 1. lockKey未关联value, 直接设置lockKey, 成功获取到锁, return true
        // 2. lock 已过期, 用getset设置lockKey, 判断返回的旧的LockInfo
        // 2.1 若仍是超时的, 则成功获取到锁, return true
        // 2.2 若不是超时的, 则进入下一次循环重新开始 步骤1
        // 3. lock没过期, 判断是否是当前线程持有
        // 3.1 是, 则计数加 1, return true
        // 3.2 否, 则进入下一次循环重新开始 步骤1
        // note: 每次进入循环都检查 : 1.是否超时, 若是则return false; 2.是否检查中断(interrupt)被中断,
        // 若需检查中断且被中断, 则抛InterruptedException
        while (useTimeout ? !isTimeout(start, timeout) : true) {
            if (interrupt) {
                checkInterruption();
            }

            long lockExpireTime = serverTimeMillis() + lockExpires + 1;// 锁超时时间
            String newLockInfoJson = LockInfo.newForCurrThread(lockExpireTime).toString();
            if (jedis.setnx(lockKey, newLockInfoJson) == 1) { // 条件能成立的唯一情况就是redis中lockKey还未关联value
                // TODO 成功获取到锁, 设置相关标识
                logger.debug("{} get lock(new), lockInfo: {}", Thread.currentThread().getName(), newLockInfoJson);
                locked = true;
                return true;
            }

            // value已有值, 但不能说明锁被持有, 因为锁可能expired了
            String currLockInfoJson = jedis.get(lockKey);
            // 若这瞬间锁被delete了
            if (currLockInfoJson == null) {
                continue;
            }

            LockInfo currLockInfo = LockInfo.fromString(currLockInfoJson);
            // 竞争条件只可能出现在锁超时的情况, 因为如果没有超时, 线程发现锁并不是被自己持有, 线程就不会去动value
            if (isTimeExpired(currLockInfo.getExpires())) {
                // 锁超时了
                LockInfo oldLockInfo = LockInfo.fromString(jedis.getSet(lockKey, newLockInfoJson));
                if (oldLockInfo != null && isTimeExpired(oldLockInfo.getExpires())) {
                    // TODO 成功获取到锁, 设置相关标识
                    logger.debug("{} get lock(new), lockInfo: {}", Thread.currentThread().getName(), newLockInfoJson);
                    locked = true;
                    return true;
                }
            } else {
                // 锁未超时, 不会有竞争情况
                if (isHeldByCurrentThread(currLockInfo)) { // 当前线程持有
                    // TODO 成功获取到锁, 设置相关标识
                    currLockInfo.setExpires(serverTimeMillis() + lockExpires + 1); // 设置新的锁超时时间
                    currLockInfo.incCount();
                    jedis.set(lockKey, currLockInfo.toString());
                    logger.debug("{} get lock(inc), lockInfo: {}", Thread.currentThread().getName(), currLockInfo);
                    locked = true;
                    return true;
                }
            }
        }
        locked = false;
        return false;
    }

    public boolean tryLock() {
        long lockExpireTime = serverTimeMillis() + lockExpires + 1;
        String newLockInfo = LockInfo.newForCurrThread(lockExpireTime).toString();

        if (jedis.setnx(lockKey, newLockInfo) == 1) {
            locked = true;
            return true;
        }

        String currLockInfoJson = jedis.get(lockKey);
        if (currLockInfoJson == null) {
            // 再一次尝试获取
            if (jedis.setnx(lockKey, newLockInfo) == 1) {
                locked = true;
                return true;
            } else {
                locked = false;
                return false;
            }
        }

        LockInfo currLockInfo = LockInfo.fromString(currLockInfoJson);

        if (isTimeExpired(currLockInfo.getExpires())) {
            LockInfo oldLockInfo = LockInfo.fromString(jedis.getSet(lockKey, newLockInfo));
            if (oldLockInfo != null && isTimeExpired(oldLockInfo.getExpires())) {
                locked = true;
                return true;
            }
        } else {
            if (isHeldByCurrentThread(currLockInfo)) {
                currLockInfo.setExpires(serverTimeMillis() + lockExpires + 1);
                currLockInfo.incCount();
                jedis.set(lockKey, currLockInfo.toString());
                locked = true;
                return true;
            }
        }
        locked = false;
        return false;
    }

    /**
     * Queries if this lock is held by any thread.
     *
     * @return {@code true} if any thread holds this lock and {@code false}
     *         otherwise
     */
    public boolean isLocked() {
        // walkthrough
        // 1. lockKey未关联value, return false
        // 2. 若 lock 已过期, return false, 否则 return true
        if (!locked) { // 本地locked为false, 肯定没加锁
            return false;
        }
        String json = jedis.get(lockKey);
        if (json == null) {
            return false;
        }
        if (isTimeExpired(LockInfo.fromString(json).getExpires())) {
            return false;
        }
        return true;
    }

    @Override
    protected void unlock0() {
        // walkthrough
        // 1. 若锁过期, return
        // 2. 判断自己是否是锁的owner
        // 2.1 是, 若 count = 1, 则删除lockKey; 若 count > 1, 则计数减 1, return
        // 2.2 否, 则抛异常 IllegalMonitorStateException, reutrn
        // done, return
        LockInfo currLockInfo = LockInfo.fromString(jedis.get(lockKey));
        if (isTimeExpired(currLockInfo.getExpires())) {
            return;
        }

        if (isHeldByCurrentThread(currLockInfo)) {
            if (currLockInfo.getCount() == 1) {
                jedis.del(lockKey);
                logger.debug("{} unlock(del), lockInfo: null", Thread.currentThread().getName());
            } else {
                currLockInfo.decCount(); // 持有锁计数减1
                String json = currLockInfo.toString();
                jedis.set(lockKey, json);
                logger.debug("{} unlock(dec), lockInfo: {}", Thread.currentThread().getName(), json);
            }
        } else {
            throw new IllegalMonitorStateException(String.format("current thread[%s] does not holds the lock", Thread.currentThread().toString()));
        }

    }

    public void release() {
        jedis.close();
        timeClient.close();
    }

    public boolean isHeldByCurrentThread() {
        return isHeldByCurrentThread(LockInfo.fromString(jedis.get(lockKey)));
    }

    // ------------------- utility methods ------------------------

    private boolean isHeldByCurrentThread(LockInfo lockInfo) {
        return lockInfo.isCurrentThread();
    }

    private void checkInterruption() throws InterruptedException {
        if (Thread.currentThread().isInterrupted()) {
            throw new InterruptedException();
        }
    }

    private boolean isTimeExpired(long time) {
        return time < serverTimeMillis();
    }

    private boolean isTimeout(long start, long timeout) {
        // 这里拿本地的时间来比较
        return start + timeout < System.currentTimeMillis();
    }

    private long serverTimeMillis() {
        return timeClient.currentTimeMillis();
    }

    private long localTimeMillis() {
        return System.currentTimeMillis();
    }

}

 

 测试

 

5个线程，每个线程都是不同的jedis连接，模拟分布式环境，线程的任务就是不断的去尝试重入地获取锁，重入的次数为随机但在0-5之间。

 

代码

 

package cc.lixiaohui.DistributedLock.DistributedLock;

import java.io.IOException;
import java.net.InetSocketAddress;
import java.net.SocketAddress;
import java.util.ArrayList;
import java.util.List;
import java.util.Random;
import java.util.concurrent.TimeUnit;

import org.junit.Test;

import redis.clients.jedis.Jedis;
import cc.lixiaohui.lock.redis.ReentrantLock;

/**
 * @author lixiaohui
 * @date 2016年9月28日 下午8:41:36
 *
 */
public class ReentrantTest {

    final int EXPIRES = 10 * 1000;

    final String LOCK_KEY = "lock.lock";

    final SocketAddress TIME_SERVER_ADDR = new InetSocketAddress("localhost", 9999);

    @Test
    public void test() throws Exception {
        // 创建5个线程不停地去重入(随机次数n, 0 <= n <=5)获取锁
        List<Thread> threads = createThreads(5);
        //开始任务
        for (Thread t : threads) {
            t.start();
        }
        // 执行60秒
        Thread.sleep(60 * 1000);
        //停止所有线程
        Task.alive = false;
        // 等待所有线程终止
        for (Thread t : threads) {
            t.join();
        }

    }
    // 创建count个线程，每个线程都是不同的jedis连接以及不同的与时间服务器的连接
    private List<Thread> createThreads(int count) throws IOException {
        List<Thread> threads = new ArrayList<Thread>();
        for (int i = 0; i < count; i++) {
            Jedis jedis = new Jedis("localhost", 6379);
            ReentrantLock lock = new ReentrantLock(jedis, LOCK_KEY, EXPIRES, TIME_SERVER_ADDR);
            Task task = new Task(lock);
            Thread t = new Thread(task);
            threads.add(t);
        }
        return threads;
    }

    private static class Task implements Runnable {

        private ReentrantLock lock;

        private final int MAX_ENTRANT = 5;

        private final Random random = new Random();

        private static boolean alive = true;

        Task(ReentrantLock lock) {
            this.lock = lock;
        }

        public void run() {
            while (alive) {
                int times = random.nextInt(MAX_ENTRANT);
                doLock(times);
            }
        }

        private void doLock(int times) {
            if (lock.tryLock(5, TimeUnit.SECONDS)) {
                try {
                    if (times > 0) {
                        doLock(--times);
                    }
                } finally {
                    if (lock != null) {
                        lock.unlock();
                    }
                }
            }

        }



    }

}

 

测试结果

 

下面是一部分日志输出：

21:09:22.328-[DEBUG] Thread-0 ReentrantLock - Thread-0 get lock(new), lockInfo: {"count":1,"expires":1475068172329,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":11}
21:09:22.330-[DEBUG] Thread-0 ReentrantLock - Thread-0 get lock(inc), lockInfo: {"count":2,"expires":1475068172330,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":11}
21:09:22.331-[DEBUG] Thread-0 ReentrantLock - Thread-0 get lock(inc), lockInfo: {"count":3,"expires":1475068172332,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":11}
21:09:22.332-[DEBUG] Thread-0 ReentrantLock - Thread-0 get lock(inc), lockInfo: {"count":4,"expires":1475068172333,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":11}
21:09:22.334-[DEBUG] Thread-0 ReentrantLock - Thread-0 get lock(inc), lockInfo: {"count":5,"expires":1475068172334,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":11}
21:09:22.335-[DEBUG] Thread-0 ReentrantLock - Thread-0 unlock(dec), lockInfo: {"count":4,"expires":1475068172334,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":11}
21:09:22.336-[DEBUG] Thread-0 ReentrantLock - Thread-0 unlock(dec), lockInfo: {"count":3,"expires":1475068172334,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":11}
21:09:22.338-[DEBUG] Thread-0 ReentrantLock - Thread-0 unlock(dec), lockInfo: {"count":2,"expires":1475068172334,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":11}
21:09:22.339-[DEBUG] Thread-0 ReentrantLock - Thread-0 unlock(dec), lockInfo: {"count":1,"expires":1475068172334,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":11}
21:09:22.340-[DEBUG] Thread-0 ReentrantLock - Thread-0 unlock(del), lockInfo: null
21:09:22.341-[DEBUG] Thread-0 ReentrantLock - Thread-0 get lock(new), lockInfo: {"count":1,"expires":1475068172341,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":11}
21:09:22.341-[DEBUG] Thread-0 ReentrantLock - Thread-0 unlock(del), lockInfo: null
21:09:22.342-[DEBUG] Thread-0 ReentrantLock - Thread-0 get lock(new), lockInfo: {"count":1,"expires":1475068172342,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":11}
21:09:22.343-[DEBUG] Thread-0 ReentrantLock - Thread-0 get lock(inc), lockInfo: {"count":2,"expires":1475068172344,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":11}
21:09:22.344-[DEBUG] Thread-0 ReentrantLock - Thread-0 unlock(dec), lockInfo: {"count":1,"expires":1475068172344,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":11}
21:09:22.345-[DEBUG] Thread-0 ReentrantLock - Thread-0 unlock(del), lockInfo: null
21:09:22.345-[DEBUG] Thread-3 ReentrantLock - Thread-3 get lock(new), lockInfo: {"count":1,"expires":1475068172345,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":14}
21:09:22.346-[DEBUG] Thread-3 ReentrantLock - Thread-3 get lock(inc), lockInfo: {"count":2,"expires":1475068172347,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":14}
21:09:22.347-[DEBUG] Thread-3 ReentrantLock - Thread-3 get lock(inc), lockInfo: {"count":3,"expires":1475068172348,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":14}
21:09:22.349-[DEBUG] Thread-3 ReentrantLock - Thread-3 get lock(inc), lockInfo: {"count":4,"expires":1475068172350,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":14}
21:09:22.350-[DEBUG] Thread-3 ReentrantLock - Thread-3 unlock(dec), lockInfo: {"count":3,"expires":1475068172350,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":14}
21:09:22.350-[DEBUG] Thread-3 ReentrantLock - Thread-3 unlock(dec), lockInfo: {"count":2,"expires":1475068172350,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":14}
21:09:22.351-[DEBUG] Thread-3 ReentrantLock - Thread-3 unlock(dec), lockInfo: {"count":1,"expires":1475068172350,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":14}
21:09:22.351-[DEBUG] Thread-3 ReentrantLock - Thread-3 unlock(del), lockInfo: null
21:09:22.352-[DEBUG] Thread-3 ReentrantLock - Thread-3 get lock(new), lockInfo: {"count":1,"expires":1475068172352,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":14}
21:09:22.352-[DEBUG] Thread-3 ReentrantLock - Thread-3 unlock(del), lockInfo: null
21:09:22.352-[DEBUG] Thread-0 ReentrantLock - Thread-0 get lock(new), lockInfo: {"count":1,"expires":1475068172353,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":11}
21:09:22.354-[DEBUG] Thread-0 ReentrantLock - Thread-0 get lock(inc), lockInfo: {"count":2,"expires":1475068172355,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":11}
21:09:22.354-[DEBUG] Thread-0 ReentrantLock - Thread-0 unlock(dec), lockInfo: {"count":1,"expires":1475068172355,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":11}
21:09:22.355-[DEBUG] Thread-0 ReentrantLock - Thread-0 unlock(del), lockInfo: null
21:09:22.355-[DEBUG] Thread-4 ReentrantLock - Thread-4 get lock(new), lockInfo: {"count":1,"expires":1475068172356,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":15}
21:09:22.357-[DEBUG] Thread-4 ReentrantLock - Thread-4 get lock(inc), lockInfo: {"count":2,"expires":1475068172357,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":15}
21:09:22.358-[DEBUG] Thread-4 ReentrantLock - Thread-4 get lock(inc), lockInfo: {"count":3,"expires":1475068172358,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":15}
21:09:22.359-[DEBUG] Thread-4 ReentrantLock - Thread-4 get lock(inc), lockInfo: {"count":4,"expires":1475068172360,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":15}
21:09:22.360-[DEBUG] Thread-4 ReentrantLock - Thread-4 unlock(dec), lockInfo: {"count":3,"expires":1475068172360,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":15}
21:09:22.361-[DEBUG] Thread-4 ReentrantLock - Thread-4 unlock(dec), lockInfo: {"count":2,"expires":1475068172360,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":15}
21:09:22.361-[DEBUG] Thread-4 ReentrantLock - Thread-4 unlock(dec), lockInfo: {"count":1,"expires":1475068172360,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":15}
21:09:22.362-[DEBUG] Thread-4 ReentrantLock - Thread-4 unlock(del), lockInfo: null
21:09:22.362-[DEBUG] Thread-0 ReentrantLock - Thread-0 get lock(new), lockInfo: {"count":1,"expires":1475068172363,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":11}
21:09:22.363-[DEBUG] Thread-0 ReentrantLock - Thread-0 get lock(inc), lockInfo: {"count":2,"expires":1475068172364,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":11}
21:09:22.365-[DEBUG] Thread-0 ReentrantLock - Thread-0 get lock(inc), lockInfo: {"count":3,"expires":1475068172365,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":11}
21:09:22.365-[DEBUG] Thread-0 ReentrantLock - Thread-0 unlock(dec), lockInfo: {"count":2,"expires":1475068172365,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":11}
21:09:22.366-[DEBUG] Thread-0 ReentrantLock - Thread-0 unlock(dec), lockInfo: {"count":1,"expires":1475068172365,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":11}
21:09:22.367-[DEBUG] Thread-0 ReentrantLock - Thread-0 unlock(del), lockInfo: null
21:09:22.367-[DEBUG] Thread-4 ReentrantLock - Thread-4 get lock(new), lockInfo: {"count":1,"expires":1475068172368,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":15}
21:09:22.368-[DEBUG] Thread-4 ReentrantLock - Thread-4 get lock(inc), lockInfo: {"count":2,"expires":1475068172369,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":15}
21:09:22.370-[DEBUG] Thread-4 ReentrantLock - Thread-4 unlock(dec), lockInfo: {"count":1,"expires":1475068172369,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":15}
21:09:22.372-[DEBUG] Thread-4 ReentrantLock - Thread-4 unlock(del), lockInfo: null
21:09:22.372-[DEBUG] Thread-1 ReentrantLock - Thread-1 get lock(new), lockInfo: {"count":1,"expires":1475068172373,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":12}
21:09:22.374-[DEBUG] Thread-1 ReentrantLock - Thread-1 get lock(inc), lockInfo: {"count":2,"expires":1475068172374,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":12}
21:09:22.375-[DEBUG] Thread-1 ReentrantLock - Thread-1 get lock(inc), lockInfo: {"count":3,"expires":1475068172376,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":12}
21:09:22.376-[DEBUG] Thread-1 ReentrantLock - Thread-1 get lock(inc), lockInfo: {"count":4,"expires":1475068172376,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":12}
21:09:22.376-[DEBUG] Thread-1 ReentrantLock - Thread-1 get lock(inc), lockInfo: {"count":5,"expires":1475068172377,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":12}
21:09:22.377-[DEBUG] Thread-1 ReentrantLock - Thread-1 unlock(dec), lockInfo: {"count":4,"expires":1475068172377,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":12}
21:09:22.377-[DEBUG] Thread-1 ReentrantLock - Thread-1 unlock(dec), lockInfo: {"count":3,"expires":1475068172377,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":12}
21:09:22.378-[DEBUG] Thread-1 ReentrantLock - Thread-1 unlock(dec), lockInfo: {"count":2,"expires":1475068172377,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":12}
21:09:22.378-[DEBUG] Thread-1 ReentrantLock - Thread-1 unlock(dec), lockInfo: {"count":1,"expires":1475068172377,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":12}
21:09:22.379-[DEBUG] Thread-1 ReentrantLock - Thread-1 unlock(del), lockInfo: null
21:09:22.379-[DEBUG] Thread-2 ReentrantLock - Thread-2 get lock(new), lockInfo: {"count":1,"expires":1475068172380,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":13}
21:09:22.380-[DEBUG] Thread-2 ReentrantLock - Thread-2 get lock(inc), lockInfo: {"count":2,"expires":1475068172380,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":13}
21:09:22.380-[DEBUG] Thread-2 ReentrantLock - Thread-2 unlock(dec), lockInfo: {"count":1,"expires":1475068172380,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":13}
21:09:22.380-[DEBUG] Thread-2 ReentrantLock - Thread-2 unlock(del), lockInfo: null
21:09:22.380-[DEBUG] Thread-3 ReentrantLock - Thread-3 get lock(new), lockInfo: {"count":1,"expires":1475068172381,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":14}
21:09:22.381-[DEBUG] Thread-3 ReentrantLock - Thread-3 get lock(inc), lockInfo: {"count":2,"expires":1475068172382,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":14}
21:09:22.381-[DEBUG] Thread-3 ReentrantLock - Thread-3 get lock(inc), lockInfo: {"count":3,"expires":1475068172382,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":14}
21:09:22.382-[DEBUG] Thread-3 ReentrantLock - Thread-3 unlock(dec), lockInfo: {"count":2,"expires":1475068172382,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":14}
21:09:22.382-[DEBUG] Thread-3 ReentrantLock - Thread-3 unlock(dec), lockInfo: {"count":1,"expires":1475068172382,"jvmPid":22224,"mac":"28-D2-44-0E-0D-9A","threadId":14}
21:09:22.382-[DEBUG] Thread-3 ReentrantLock - Thread-3 unlock(del), lockInfo: null

 看日志输出，lockInfo对应的json就是redis中lockKey对应的值，可以看到这个重入锁正常工作(count先递增后递减，在count不为0时别的线程拿不到锁)。测试通过，性能上还待改善

 

 

Thinking again

 

如何实现读写锁？

 

目前想出的一种实现是redis中存两个键值对，一个读一个写，随之而来的一个问题是：对于加锁过程，可能会要求对这两个键值的更改（这里指一起更改两者）要具有原子性，因此得用一个额外的重入锁，来同步这个操作。但这样实现未免代价太大，仍思考解决方法中..........路过的大神请指条明路...

 

 代码放这里了：戳我

评论

2 楼 莫名的拉风 2016-11-26  

AiJava* 写道

超时与unlock哪儿应该有点问题,如果上次持有锁有线程超时但还没有释放锁，
此时锁可以被另一个线程抢占，但上次持有锁有线程再释放时，
if (Thread.currentThread() != getExclusiveOwnerThread()) {
             // 如果超时了,但自己还没有unlock，此时已被其它线程抢占了锁
            throw new IllegalMonitorStateException("current thread does not hold the lock"+Thread.currentThread().getId());
        }
这儿就抛异常了吧

是的，之前已经把Thread exclusiveOwnerThread这个字段去掉了，在多进程环境中这个字段根本就没啥用，实现重入时就考虑到把当前持有锁线程的标识存到了redis上，忘了更新博客

1 楼 AiJava* 2016-11-24  

超时与unlock哪儿应该有点问题,如果上次持有锁有线程超时但还没有释放锁，
此时锁可以被另一个线程抢占，但上次持有锁有线程再释放时，
if (Thread.currentThread() != getExclusiveOwnerThread()) {
             // 如果超时了,但自己还没有unlock，此时已被其它线程抢占了锁
            throw new IllegalMonitorStateException("current thread does not hold the lock"+Thread.currentThread().getId());
        }
这儿就抛异常了吧