`
supportopensource
  • 浏览: 521773 次
  • 性别: Icon_minigender_1
  • 来自: 杭州
社区版块
存档分类
最新评论

Desktop Linux: The Dream Is Dead

阅读更多
It kills me to say this: The dream of Linux as a major desktop OS is now pretty much dead.

Despite phenomenal security and stability--and amazing strides in usability, performance, and compatibility--Linux simply isn’t catching on with desktop users. And if there ever was a chance for desktop Linux to succeed, that ship has long since sunk.

Over the past few years, modern Linux distributions such as Ubuntu have utterly transformed the open-source desktop user experience into something sleek and simple, while arguably surpassing Windows and Mac OS in both security and stability. Meanwhile, the public failure of Windows Vista and the rise of the netbook gave Linux some openings to capture a meaningful slice of the market. But those opportunities have been squandered and lost, and Linux desktop market share remains stagnant at around 1 percent.

I should emphasize that I'm not by any means talking about the demise of Linux itself. New projections from the Linux Foundation credibly show that demand for Linux on servers will outstrip demand for all other options over the next few years. And, as I'll discuss at length in this article, Linux has already established itself as a dominant operating system on mobile and embedded devices ranging from tablets and phones to TVs and printers.

But for anyone who has longed for a future in which free, open-source Linux distributions would rival premium commercial operating systems from Microsoft and Apple on desktop PCs, now might be a good time to set more-realistic expectations. Though I personally wish that the opposite were true, the year of the Linux desktop will never come.

Missed Opportunities

A few years ago, I infamously went on record with the belief that the stage had been set for a significant breakthrough in Linux adoption rates. After all, Ubuntu had created a virtually idiot-proof distribution that was as easy to install as Windows or Mac OS X. Hardware driver support had reached critical mass. Even major PC makers such as Dell had stepped up to offer Linux as a preinstalled option on laptops and desktops.

At the same time, consumer sentiment toward Windows Vista had reached such abysmal depths that users were clamoring for other options. And to sweeten the prospects just a bit more, the emergence of netbooks gave Linux a nearly unchallenged new platform to dominate for months on end. If there was ever a time for Linux to rise up, 2008 was that time. But it wasn't meant to be.

Although Asus managed to spark a massive trend with cheap, simple netbook PCs, it opted to ship systems preinstalled with a Xandros distribution that left a lot to be desired. Other vendors moved just as clumsily with a host of bad options that gave Microsoft room to sweep the market by extending the life of Windows XP. In that one gesture, all hope was lost for Linux's netbook revolution. Meanwhile, desktop users who fled Windows Vista mostly just switched to Macs or reverted to Windows XP.

By the time Microsoft released the Windows 7 beta in January 2009, Linux had clearly lost its chance at desktop glory.

Why Linux Failed on the Desktop

The failure of Linux to catch on with mainstream PC users will come as no great surprise to most observers, but the reasons for its failure are often misunderstood or, at the very least, grossly misstated. Linux didn't fail on the desktop because it's "too geeky," "too hard to use," or "too obscure," as casual detractors so often claim in online forums. On the contrary, the best-known distribution--Ubuntu--has received high marks for usability from every major player in the technology press, and it features a menu layout nearly identical to that of Mac OS X.

Ultimately, Linux is doomed on the desktop because of a critical lack of content. And that lack of content owes its existence to two key factors: the fragmentation of the Linux platform, and the fierce ideology of the open-source community at large.

User expectations have shifted dramatically in the past few years, and it's no longer acceptable for any PC to fail at basic media viewing. DVD playback and video streaming from premium sites such as Netflix are now fundamental capabilities that any computer should have. But the politics of the open-source world make that a nearly hopeless dream for Linux.

"I share the hope with everyone that free and open-source software will rise to meet the requirements of content delivery," says longtime Linux developer Jeff Whatcott, senior vice president of marketing for Brightcove, a company that specializes in online video streaming. "But that's not happening."

"DRM is not popular with the open-source crowd," says Whatcott, lamenting that the open-source community at large remains so steadfastly opposed to digital rights management technologies. Without those systems, commercial content providers have no incentive to embrace Linux. And Whatcott points out that even if the open-source community were willing to go along, the DRM arena is dominated by "deep, deep patent pools," making a free, open-source alternative unlikely anyway.

Meanwhile, even common streaming technologies such as Flash--which Whatcott helped bring to Linux in his previous role as a Macromedia (and later Adobe) product manager--deliver poor results on Linux.

"It wasn't for lack of trying," Whatcott says. "At the time, Macromedia put extensive resources into figuring that out." But despite the hard work of a team of engineers "that loved Linux," the fragmentation of the Linux platform and the hurdles presented by what Whatcott describes as "alpha-quality" drivers for audio and video hardware made success elusive for the Flash development team.

We shouldn't be too hard on Linux, though. After all, there are stark signs that the desktop itself is becoming irrelevant.

"The war between cloud and native apps has already been won on the desktop," says Guy Ben-Artzi, CEO of Particle Code, which makes cross-platform tools for mobile-app developers. "When it comes to desktop development, everything is moving to Web technology. If I was really pushing for Linux right now, I would not be focusing on desktop applications." Instead, says Ben-Artzi, Linux proponents should push aggressively for open Web platforms.

Kevin Mahaffey, CTO of mobile security company Lookout, agrees. "Linux can be successful on the desktop if it has a great Web experience," says Mahaffey. "The growth of things like HTML5 will help to give Linux a user experience that's on par with other platforms."

According to all of my sources, if there's any last hope for Linux on the desktop, it's HTML5. As the next-generation Web standard establishes a common set of open media-streaming technologies, it will offer a glimmer of hope to those who want to maintain Linux as their desktop OS, increasing the odds that whatever content or services they want to use will work on their open-source PC. Of course, that's assuming the DRM problems magically disappear.

"In a strange way," says Brightcove's Jeff Whatcott, "iOS may save the Linux desktop indirectly." Brightcove has thrown its resources into developing HTML5 streaming tools, and according to Whatcott, "what's driving that is iOS."

But if Linux ever manages to win equal footing with Windows or Mac OS X in a cloud-centric world, it will likely be a hollow victory, made possible only through the sheer irrelevance of the operating system itself.

Our Mobile Future

"Forget about the desktop," Phil Robb, director of HP's Open Source Programs Office, tells Linux developers. "I think that's not where the effort should be put."

Rather than continue to fight for a tiny sliver of desktop market share, Robb says developers should concentrate on areas where Linux is strong. "Linux is already strong on small, mobile devices. If you're looking for ubiquity and impact on the planet, the Linux community should pat themselves on the back because they've already secured a victory on mobile."

And it looks like Robb is right. Even before Google's Android emerged, LG and other companies had turned to Linux to power the underpinnings of feature phones. Now Android and, to a lesser degree so far, WebOS (which HP recently acquired in its buyout of Palm) are putting Linux at the forefront of smartphone and tablet innovation.

Simultaneously, Linux has emerged as the go-to platform for embedded systems that power Web-enabled HDTVs and set-top boxes ranging from Roku and Google TV to Boxee and a multitude of others. Of course, to the end user, Linux is transparent in these offerings, and the experience is a far cry from what traditional Linux desktop enthusiasts have come to know and love. Notably, these implementations tend to be closed rather than open, showing only a simple set of menus to the end user.

End of the Road?

It has been a long trek since Linus Torvalds wrote the first Linux kernel as a college project in 1992, and the landscape has shifted considerably along the way. Despite grim prospects on the desktop, Linux has clearly asserted itself as a major platform that's here to stay. And of course, passionate open-source proponents will rightly stand by their favorite desktop distributions despite the challenges ahead.

But at this point in history, it's hard to deny the evidence: With stagnant market growth and inadequate content options compounded by industry inertia, Linux basically has no chance to rival Mac OS X, much less Windows.

原文地址:http://www.pcworld.com/businesscenter/article/207999-1/desktop_linux_the_dream_is_dead.html
分享到:
评论

相关推荐

    ArcGIS Desktop安装:ArcGIS Desktop9_2+XP篇详细图文教程.mht

    ArcGIS Desktop安装:ArcGIS Desktop9_2+XP篇详细图文教程.mht

    GitHubDesktop-linux-2.6.6-linux1.deb

    适用于Ubuntu的Github desktop安装文件,deb安装。先运行如下:apt install gconf2 libappindicator1 gconf-service...适用于Linux的GitHub desktop各类安装包下载地址:https://github.com/shiftkey/desktop/releases

    Oracle Solaris 8 Common Desktop Environment: ICommon Desktop Env

    《Oracle Solaris 8 Common Desktop Environment: ICommon Desktop Env》是针对Oracle Solaris 8操作系统中集成的桌面环境——Common Desktop Environment(CDE)的一份技术指南和认证检查列表。Oracle Solaris 8是...

    Oracle Solaris 9 Solaris Common Desktop Environment: User’s Tran

    Oracle Solaris 9 Solaris Common Desktop Environment: User’s Transition Guide-28

    linux中redis安装包和redis-desktop-manager-0.9.3.817

    本文将详细讲解如何在Linux上安装Redis,包括Redis 4.0.2和5.0.0两个版本,以及如何配合使用Redis Desktop Manager进行图形化管理。 首先,我们来了解Redis的基本概念。Redis是一个基于内存的数据结构存储系统,...

    Windows 7安装ArcGIS DeskTop10:错误1935,安装程序

    Windows 7 安装 ArcGIS DeskTop10 错误 1935 解决方案 在 Windows 7 操作系统中安装 ArcGIS DeskTop10 时,可能会出现错误 1935,阻止安装程序的完成。这是因为锐捷软件的 BUG 导致卸载不完全,留下注册表中的安装...

    desktop配置

    请勿在未经授权的情况下上传任何涉及著作权侵权的资源,除非该资源完全由您个人创作

    Symantec_Encryption_Desktop_10.4.2_MP3_Linux.rar

    《Symantec Encryption Desktop 10.4.2 MP3 for Linux:安全电子邮件加密的基石》 在数字化时代,信息安全已经成为个人和企业不可或缺的关注点。Symantec Encryption Desktop 10.4.2 MP3 for Linux是Symantec公司...

    U盘安装RedFlag-Desktop-11.0红旗Linux系统

    本文将详细介绍如何通过U盘安装RedFlag-Desktop-11.0红旗Linux系统,这对于那些希望在实体机上体验红旗Linux的用户来说非常实用。 首先,你需要准备以下材料: 1. 一个8GB或更大的U盘,用于制作启动盘。 2. U盘启动...

    Novell Linux Desktop Training

    根据给定文件的信息,我们可以提炼出关于“Novell Linux Desktop Training”的相关知识点。 ### Novell Linux Desktop Training #### 一、课程概述 本课程旨在提供关于Novell Linux桌面操作系统的全面培训,帮助...

    ipfs-desktop:Windows,Mac和Linux上用于IPFS的简单易用且用户友好的桌面应用程序

    Linux:请参阅下面的 目录 或 产品特点 IPFS桌面将完整的IPFS节点(运行 )和到一个便捷的桌面应用程序中-并在OS菜单栏/系统托盘中添加了一个菜单,可轻松访问各种常见的IPFS任务。 如果您的计算机上已经有一个...

    redis-desktop for Linux

    redis-desktop deb安装包,并且包含安装时所需要的包依赖,适用于ubuntu16.04,亲测可以使用,安装方式: sudo dpkg -i xxxx.deb,需要注意的是,需要注意的是需要先安装其他包依赖,再安装redis-desktop,安装成功...

    Red Hat Enterprise Linux 7: Desktops and Administration

    This book examines Red Hat Enterprise Linux 7 for the desktop user and administrator. Though administrative tools are covered, the emphasis is on what a user would need to know to perform tasks. The ...

    flutter_audio_desktop:[WIP] Flutter Desktop的:musical_note:音频播放库。 支持Windows和Linux。 基于miniaudio

    Flutter Desktop的音频播放库。 随时打开问题。 正在安装 在您的pubspec.yaml中提及: dependencies : ... flutter_audio_desktop : ^0.1.0 使用 // Create new instance. var audioPlayer = new AudioPlayer ...

    mac上Parallels Desktop安装kali linux 2020.2a并安装好Parallels Tools+Goo

    在Mac上使用Parallels Desktop (PD) 安装Kali Linux 2020.2a是一项常见的任务,尤其对于需要进行网络安全测试或开发的用户来说。Parallels Desktop是一款强大的虚拟化软件,它允许用户在Mac系统上运行多个操作系统,...

    Arch Linux Desktop Install:Arch Linux桌面安装程序-开源

    #archdi只需一个简单的bash脚本向导,即可使用Arch Linux安装和配置完整的个人计算机。 首先,使用官方媒体(可选)和archfi安装Arch Linux。 查看archfi项目,开始安装arch linux:...

    Foxit Reader for Desktop Linux

    **Foxit Reader for Desktop Linux** 是一款专为Linux桌面环境设计的免费PDF文档阅读器和打印工具,由福昕软件开发。此软件以其轻巧的体积、快速的启动速度和全面的功能著称,旨在提供一个高效且用户友好的PDF阅读...

    Linux 下的迅雷 xware-desktop

    Xware Desktop作为Xware(迅雷固件)的前端,是一次将用于嵌入式设备的迅雷软件带到Linux桌面的一次尝试。本软件与迅雷官方没有任何关系。 Xware Desktop的目标是提供与Windows平台上迅雷相当的功能。你可以这样...

    Red Flag Linux Desktop 5.0 手册

    Red Flag Linux Desktop 5.0 作为红旗的新一代操作系统,在硬件设备支持、系统安装、核心性能、桌 面环境设计等方面做出了较大改进,使之更加适用于政府、家庭、个人的办公、教育、开发、学习、娱乐 等方面的需求;...

Global site tag (gtag.js) - Google Analytics