解决OCFS2的o2net_connect_expired问题

接上次的文章，在修改/etc/sysconfig/o2cb的配置后，发现两机器只有一台可以自动挂载ocfs2分区，而另外一台不能自动挂载。但启动完毕后，手动挂载正常。
一、详细情况
两机器分别是dbsrv-1和dbsrv-2，使用交叉线做网络心跳，并在cluster.conf中使用私有心跳IP，非公用IP地址。
1、检查o2cb状态
启动后，o2cb服务是启动正常的，ocfs2模块也加载正常的，但心跳是Not Active：

引用

Checking heartbeat: Not Active

2、检查/etc/fstab文件

引用

#cat /etc/fstab|grep ocfs2
/dev/sdc1    /oradata   ocfs2   _netdev,datavolume,nointr 0 0

配置正确；
3、检查两机器的/etc/ocfs2/cluster.conf内容

引用

# more /etc/ocfs2/cluster.conf
node:
       ip_port = 7777
       ip_address = 172.20.3.2
       number = 0
       name = dbsrv-2
       cluster = ocfs2

node:
       ip_port = 7777
       ip_address = 172.20.3.1
       number = 1
       name = dbsrv-1
       cluster = ocfs2

cluster:
       node_count = 2
       name = ocfs2

已经确认，两机器该文件是完全相同的。
4、查看系统日志
报错信息如下：

引用

Jul 20 19:33:18 dbsrv-2 kernel: OCFS2 1.2.3
Jul 20 19:33:24 dbsrv-2 kernel: (4452,0):o2net_connect_expired:1446 ERROR: no connection established with node 1 after 10 seconds, giving up and returning errors.
Jul 20 19:33:24 dbsrv-2 kernel: (4478,2):dlm_request_join:786 ERROR: status = -107
Jul 20 19:33:24 dbsrv-2 kernel: (4478,2):dlm_try_to_join_domain:934 ERROR: status = -107
Jul 20 19:33:24 dbsrv-2 kernel: (4478,2):dlm_join_domain:1186 ERROR: status = -107
Jul 20 19:33:24 dbsrv-2 kernel: (4478,2):dlm_register_domain:1379 ERROR: status = -107
Jul 20 19:33:24 dbsrv-2 kernel: (4478,2):ocfs2_dlm_init:2009 ERROR: status = -107
Jul 20 19:33:24 dbsrv-2 kernel: (4478,2):ocfs2_mount_volume:1062 ERROR: status = -107
Jul 20 19:33:24 dbsrv-2 kernel: ocfs2: Unmounting device (8,33) on (node 0)
Jul 20 19:33:26 dbsrv-2 mount: mount.ocfs2: Transport endpoint is not connected
Jul 20 19:33:26 dbsrv-2 mount:
Jul 20 19:33:26 dbsrv-2 netfs: Mounting other filesystems:  failed

二、分析问题
1、node节点的启动顺序
从Google搜索到如此的信息：

引用

Mount triggers the heartbeat thread which triggers the o2net
to make a connection to all heartbeating nodes. If this connection
fails,the mount fails. (The larger node number initiates the connection
to the lower node number.)

说明o2cb启动的时候，是根据node节点的大小顺序启动的。
而在cluster.conf中，node0是dbsrv-2，node1是dbsrv-1，所以，dbsrv-1在启动的时候马上可联通本机IP，然后挂载ocfs2分区；但dbsrv-2启动的时候，则不能即时发现对方IP地址，所以启动失败。
2、尝试修改HEARTBEAT_THRESHOLD参数
从Goolge搜索到另外一条信息：

引用

After confirming with Stephan, this problem appears to relate to the HEARTBEAT_THRESHOLD parameter as set in /etc/sysconfig/o2cb. After encountering this myself and having confirmed with a couple of other people in the list that it has caused problems, it seems that the default threshold of 7 is possibly too short, even in reasonably fast server-storage solutions such as an HP DL380 Packaged Cluster.

Does the OCFS2 development team also consider this to be too short, or is altering the paramater just a workaround that shouldn't be used? If this is the case then how should we approach the problem of self-fencing nodes?

Also, can we expect this behaviour with some platforms but not others, or is it too short for all platforms? If it is a blanket problem, then should the default threshold be raised?

Finally, if the altering the threshold is a valid solution, could it please be added to the FAQs and the user guide so that people know to adjust it as a first step on encountering the problem, rather than having to post to the list and wait for replies.

并参考网上的资料，修改/etc/sysconfig/o2cb的HEARTBEAT_THRESHOLD参数为301，启动后报：

引用

Jul 23 13:59:50 dbsrv-2 kernel: (4477,0):o2hb_check_slot:883 ERROR: Node 1 on device sdc1 has a dead count of 14000 ms, but our count is 602000 ms.
Jul 23 13:59:50 dbsrv-2 kernel: Please double check your configuration values for 'O2CB_HEARTBEAT_THRESHOLD'
Jul 23 13:59:54 dbsrv-2 kernel: OCFS2 1.2.3
Jul 23 14:00:00 dbsrv-2 kernel: (4449,0):o2net_connect_expired:1446 ERROR: no connection established with node 1 after 10 seconds, giving up and returning errors.
Jul 23 14:00:00 dbsrv-2 kernel: (4475,2):dlm_request_join:786 ERROR: status = -107

问题依旧。
※注释

引用

[隔离时间（秒）] = (O2CB_HEARTBEAT_THRESHOLD - 1) * 2
(301 - 1) * 2 = 600 秒

综上所述，已经能清楚所有配置都是正确的。
导致故障的原因是：
在启动o2cb服务的前，由于某些原因，o2cb依赖的IP地址未能及时取得联系，操作了其限定的时间，而启动失败。而在机器完整启动后，网络已经正常，所以，手动挂载ocfs2分区正常。

三、解决问题
1、Oracle metalink给出的信息

引用

The problem here is that network layer not becoming fully functional even  after /etc/init.d/network script is done executing. The proposed patch is a  work around and is not fixing a problem in o2cb script.

2、解决方法

引用

a）确保所有配置文件都正确，无差异；
b）确保两服务器的机器时间不要相差太远；
（可使用时间同步）
c）o2cb使用的cluster.conf文件中，应使用心跳IP，而非公网IP
d）修改/etc/init.d/o2cb脚本，在最前面加入一个sleep的延迟时间，以等待网络正常；
e）实在还是不行，把启动脚本放到/etc/rc.local中

mount -t ocfs2 -o datavolume,nointr /dev/sdc1 /oradata
/etc/init.d/init.crs start

四、已知可能的原因
1、磁盘原因
例如使用iSCSI、Firewire等做盘柜，可能因读取时间长，引发timeout导致问题；
2、网络原因
如果使用公网IP做o2cb的判断，则由于在加载网卡驱动后，交换机未能及时通讯（特别是Cisco的交换机），导致IP通讯失败；
如果使用心跳IP做o2cb的判断，则有部分网卡在加载驱动后，未能马上激活，并与对方网卡联通而导致失败。
总体来说，都是和硬件的关系比较多。

分享到：

Oracle学习笔记之RMAN备份 | Oracle调优总结

• 2008-12-02 20:26
• 浏览 1848
• 评论(0)
• 查看更多